The fund most American workers never chose is starting to hold assets most of them have never seen.

How Private Assets Found Their Way Into the Default Option
A target-date fund is built around a single decision: the year a saver expects to retire. The fund starts heavy in stocks and gradually shifts toward bonds as that year approaches, a schedule known as the glide path. Because these funds qualify as default investments under federal rules, they collect the contributions of workers who never pick anything from the plan menu. For a large share of 401(k) participants, the target-date fund is the entire retirement strategy.
The case for adding private markets rests on three arguments. Private equity, private credit, real estate and infrastructure are said to offer returns that public stocks and bonds cannot, partly as compensation for tying money up. They may also move differently from public markets, which could soften the damage in a rough year. And companies now stay private far longer than they once did, so the public market holds a smaller slice of the economy’s growth than it used to.
Policy has added momentum. An executive order signed in August 2025 directed federal regulators to revisit how retirement plans can offer alternative assets, and the order was widely read as an invitation to the industry to build products. Large asset managers and recordkeepers have spent the time since developing target-date versions with private sleeves. Employers, who choose the funds on the plan menu, are the ones being asked to decide whether to adopt them.
Most of these designs keep the private allocation modest and wrap it in a pooled vehicle that also holds plenty of ordinary, easily sold securities. The structure is meant to reassure. A small private slice, surrounded by liquid holdings, should not disrupt daily trading for participants. Whether that holds up under stress is exactly what critics are asking.
Where the Scrutiny Is Landing
Liquidity is the first pressure point. A target-date fund promises that participants can move money in and out on any business day at a fair price. Private assets do not trade on exchanges, so the fund must raise cash for withdrawals from its public holdings or through special arrangements with other investors. In calm markets this works quietly. In a panic, when many participants sell at once, the liquid portion shrinks first and the illiquid portion becomes a larger share of what remains.
Valuation is the second. Public stocks are repriced every second, but private holdings are marked by appraisal, often quarterly, and the marks tend to lag the market. That lag can make a portfolio look calmer than it really is, which flatters its risk statistics. It also creates a fairness problem inside a pooled fund. If a private asset is carried at a stale, too-high value during a downturn, a worker who sells that day takes out more than the holding is worth, and the participants who stay behind absorb the difference. If marks are too low during a recovery, the reverse happens, and the transfer runs toward new buyers. A fund that sits at the center of millions of accounts has to get this right every time, not on average.

Fees are the third. The target-date category became popular partly because competition drove costs down, and low-cost index versions are now widely available. Private strategies come with higher management charges and often performance fees, and those costs sit on top of the fund’s own. The question for any sponsor is whether the extra return, after every layer of cost, actually reaches the participant. Gross performance figures from private funds can look attractive while the net outcome is ordinary.
Employers carry the legal weight. Under federal retirement law, the company choosing the fund is a fiduciary and must show a prudent process. The industry has seen a long run of lawsuits over plan fees, and that history makes many sponsors cautious about adopting anything that is hard to explain to a judge.
Then there is transparency. Institutions that hold private assets, such as defined benefit pension plans, employ investment staff, can lock up capital for a decade and do not face individual workers demanding their balance on a Tuesday afternoon. A 401(k) participant has none of those protections. The person holding the account cannot inspect the underlying loans or buyout stakes, cannot easily judge the valuation, and is unlikely to read the footnotes in a fund fact sheet.
What Sponsors and Savers Should Be Asking
The useful questions are specific. How large is the private allocation, and how does it change along the glide path? Who sets the valuations, and how often are they checked against actual sale prices? What is the plan if redemptions spike, and who bears the cost of meeting them? What is the all-in fee, and what would the same fund cost without the private sleeve? A sponsor that cannot get plain answers to these has a reason to wait.

The irony is that the young saver, with decades before retirement, is the one best suited to give up liquidity for a possible return premium. That same saver is the least likely to know the fund holds anything unusual at all.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are target-date funds adding private market investments?
Fund providers argue that private equity, credit, real estate and infrastructure can improve diversification and offer return potential not available in public markets. Companies staying private longer and recent policy changes have also encouraged the move.
What are the main risks of private assets in a target-date fund?
The main concerns are liquidity during heavy withdrawals, appraisal-based valuations that can lag the market, and higher fees. Participants also have limited visibility into what the underlying assets are worth.
How can I tell if my target-date fund holds private investments?
Check the fund’s fact sheet, prospectus or plan disclosures for allocations to private equity, private credit or similar categories. Your plan administrator can also explain the allocation and its fees.






